• Offered by School of Philosophy
  • ANU College ANU College of Arts and Social Sciences
  • Course subject Philosophy
  • Areas of interest Philosophy, Psychology, Economics, Artifical Intelligence, Politics
  • Academic career Undergraduate
  • Mode of delivery In Person

This course examines what it means to be 'rational' in negotiating the world and conducting one's life. At issue is the quality of one's beliefs, desires and choices about how to act, particularly in the face of uncertainty, and in concert with others.

Part I is a critical examination of the standard theory of individual rationality - expected utility theory - that unites and explicates the aforementioned key mental attitudes. This theory stems from the classic work of philosophers/social scientists such as Ramsey, de Finetti and Savage. Contemporary challenges to the standard theory come from diverse directions, with some arguing that the theory is too little constrained and even vacuous, others arguing that it is too rigid, either in its prescriptions for representing and handling uncertainty or else by virtue of being in conflict with some prominent ethical accounts of right action, and yet others arguing that it gives outright bad advice in various special cases. The course considers these challenges to the standard theory and the responses/developments they have inspired.

Part II turns to rationality in a social context. The initial focus is the theory of games, applicable to cases where what an individual should do depends on what others do, and vice versa. Standard solution concepts for games are introduced, and the collective-action problems that may arise, including possibilities for their resolution, are considered, with an eye to the ethical significance of these scenarios. Finally, the course turns to group choice proper, where individuals effectively join forces and act as a single entity. Here the starting point for investigation is Arrow's theorem regarding the (im)possibility of an adequate group aggregation of individual attitudes; this invites examination of Arrow's assumptions, and raises further questions regarding interpersonal comparability and the plausibility of Utilitarianism and other aggregative solutions. 

Learning Outcomes

Upon successful completion of this course, students will have the knowledge and skills to:

  1. Understand and articulate key philosophical issues pertaining to rational choice and inference, both for individuals and groups
  2. Engage with and critically evaluate (in essay form) formal and discursive material relevant to individual, game and social choice theory
  3. Engage in well-reasoned, justified and articulate discussion and debate.

Indicative Assessment

1 x mid-semester take-home exam (15%) (Learning Outcome 1)

1 x 2000-word essay (30%) (Learning Outcomes 1 and 2)

1 x 2500-word essay (45%) (Learning Outcomes 1 and 2)

Tutorial participation (10%) (Learning Outcomes 1 and 3)

The ANU uses Turnitin to enhance student citation and referencing techniques, and to assess assignment submissions as a component of the University's approach to managing Academic Integrity. While the use of Turnitin is not mandatory, the ANU highly recommends Turnitin is used by both teaching staff and students. For additional information regarding Turnitin please visit the ANU Online website.

Workload

Weekly lectures plus tutorials

130 hours of total student learning time made up from:

a) 35 hours of contact: 24 hours of lectures and 11 hours of tutorials.

b) 95 hours of independent student research, technical exercises, reading and writing, supported by WATTLE recordings and lecture notes.

Requisite and Incompatibility

6 units of Philosophy (PHIL) courses, or with permission of the course convenor.

Indicative Reading List

Richard Jeffrey, 'The Logic of Decision', Michael Resnik, 'Choices: an introduction to decision theory', Martin Peterson 'An Introduction to Decision Theory', Amartya Sen 'Collective Choice and Social Welfare', Duncan Luce and Howard Raiffa 'Games and Decisions', Wulf Gaertner 'A Primer in Social Choice Theory', J. S. Kelly 'Social Choice Theory. An Introduction', Daniel Hausman and Michael McPherson 'Economic Analysis, Moral Philosophy and Public Policy'.

Majors

Minors

Fees

Tuition fees are for the academic year indicated at the top of the page.  

If you are a domestic graduate coursework or international student you will be required to pay tuition fees. Tuition fees are indexed annually. Further information for domestic and international students about tuition and other fees can be found at Fees.

Student Contribution Band:
Band 1
Unit value:
6 units

If you are an undergraduate student and have been offered a Commonwealth supported place, your fees are set by the Australian Government for each course. At ANU 1 EFTSL is 48 units (normally 8 x 6-unit courses). You can find your student contribution amount for each course at Fees.  Where there is a unit range displayed for this course, not all unit options below may be available.

Units EFTSL
6.00 0.12500
Note: Please note that fee information is for current year only.

Responsible Officer: Registrar, Student Administration / Page Contact: Website Administrator / Frequently Asked Questions